Rudy Giuliani was reportedly unmasked as a contestant during last week’s taping of FOX’s The Masked Singer, prompting judges Ken Jeong and Robin Thicke to leave the stage in protest. According to Deadline, Jeong and Thicke eventually returned to set, while Jenny McCarthy and Nicole Scherzinger stayed put. Apparently the reveal won’t actually air until next month (the game show’s seventh season premieres March 9).